SENSE, REFERENCE, & CATS | FREGE/RUSSELL DEBATE

Sense, Reference, & Cats | Frege/Russell Debate Thumbnail

When it comes to language, how does it relate to reality? Signs, sense, reference, definite descriptions or denoting phrases, definite & indefinite articles. How do we understand the sense & reference of fictional objects? What objects do their names refer to, and what type of reality do they have? How is it possible to refer to something that doesn’t exist? What kind of sense could a definite description like “the present emperor of CHINA” have since there is no denotation for “the present emperor of CHINA?” Are statements about non-existent entities true or false? How does our sense of the way language relates to reality change when we speak of the unreal? So, is sense superfluous as Russell says? Or, can sense be rescued beyond the shackles of the nominatum? This video will explore all of these concepts and is itself a sign referring to the famous Frege/Russell debate about Sense & Reference.

VIEW MORE

PHILOSOPHY

Works Cited:

Frege, Gottlob. “On Sense and Nominatum (1892).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 190–202. Buy here:!

Russell, Bertrand. “On Denoting (1905).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 203–211. Buy here:!

Russell, Bertrand. “Descriptions (1919).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 212–218. Buy here:!

Strawson, P.F. “On Referring (1950).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 219–234. Buy here:!

Farmer, Philip Jose. Riders of the Purple Wage. Buy here!

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Instagram
Patreon

Science Fiction & Logic Time

On this day, many a sun ago, science-fiction author Philip Jose Farmer was born. In celebration of his memory, I present to you this video about science fiction and logic.

(January 26, 1918-February 25, 2009)

Let’s look at these two statements:

1. PJF is PJF. (Grammatically)
p=p (Logically)
Necessarily true.
Trivial

2. PJF is the author of Riders of the Purple Wage. (Grammatically)
Ǝx [Axr & ∀y(Ayr →y=x) & x=p] (Logically)
Contingently true.
Informative.

Check out these science fiction books:
Riders of the Purple Wage by Philip Jose Farmer

Dangerous Visions Edited by Harlan Ellison

The Philip José Farmer Centennial Collection by Philip Jose Farmer

Learn more about Philip Jose Farmer @ PJFarmer.com.

Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Patreon

Sense & Reference: Fictional Names

How do we understand the sense & reference of fictional objects? What objects do their names refer to, and what type of reality do they have?

We continue the Frege/Russell debate in linguistics by looking at the fictional work of science-fiction author Philip Jose Farmer.

Bertrand Russell voiced by Alexander Moneypenny.

Music sampled from Zoë Blade.

Artwork of Chibiabos Elgreco Winnegan by Crissha.s.art.

Works Cited:
Frege, Gottlob. “On Sense and Nominatum (1892).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 190–202.

Russell, Bertrand. “On Denoting (1905).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 203–211.

Russell, Bertrand. “Descriptions (1919).” The Philosophy of Language, edited by Aloysius Martinich, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 212–218.

Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Patreon

Chibiabos Elgreco Winnegan

I present to you the first known artist rendering of Chibiabos Elgreco Winnegan, the protagonist of the Novella Riders of the Purple Wage, written by Philip Jose Farmer.

Commissioned by Zach Gittrich 2021 in the year of our Lord.

Drawn by Crissha.s.art.

Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Patreon

error

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)

RSS